The two streams of the Goetia — how it reached us

✦

What people call «the Goetia» is not one river but two overlapping streams we usually collapse into one. The list of 72 is late; many of its spirits are far older.

One Goetia, or two

On one side is the northern literary stream: the line of the spirit-catalogues that runs from the Livre des Esperitz and the Liber Officiorum Spirituum (15th–16th c.) to Weyer's Pseudomonarchia (1577), then to Scot's Discoverie of Witchcraft (1584), and at last to the Lemegeton (mid-17th c.) and the Mathers & Crowley edition (1904). This is the one this site maps. On the other, the southern folk stream: the clerical-popular magic of the Mediterranean (Italy, Spain, southern France, Greece) that flows into the Grimorium Verum (18th c.), with a different scaffolding —the Three Chiefs, Lucifer, Beelzebub and Astaroth, through the go-between Scirlin— and an art of the pact. They share part of the cast of spirits, but their framework differs.

Common medieval stock · 14th c.
Summa Sacrae Magicae — Berengar Ganell (c. 1346)
Codifies the four cardinal kings and the Three Chiefs over the sublunary world.
▼

Northern stream · literary

15th–16th c.Livre des Esperitz · Liber Officiorum Spirituum
Catalogues built on the 4 cardinal kings. Witnesses: Trinity O.8.29, Folger V.b.26, Wellcome MS 110. → library
1577Pseudomonarchia Daemonum
Weyer, appendix to De praestigiis daemonum. → library
1584Discoverie of Witchcraft
Reginald Scot carries the list into English.
~1650Lemegeton · Ars Goetia
The 72 spirits with their seals, for the first time.
1904Mathers & Crowley Goetia
The version almost everyone knows. → the 72

Southern stream · folk / diabolist

MediterraneanClerical-popular magic
Italy, Spain, southern France and Greece. Keeps the Three Chiefs and direct dealing.
18th c.Grimorium Verum
Lucifer, Beelzebub and Astaroth through Scirlin; a pact with simple materials. We cover it in our «Other Goetia» series.

The fall of the Three Chiefs

The most telling detail is what became of the Three Chiefs. In the Livre des Esperitz they are still spirits 1, 2 and 3 —Lucifer, Beelzebub and Satan— before the four kings, with Lucifer also up in the header. In the Liber Officiorum (the Folger English copy) they survive only as an aside: «there be 3 devills in the art of Nigromancy: Lucifer, Beelzebub, Satan»… and the text moves straight on to the kings and the office-list. You can watch the flattening happen from one witness to the next. And there is a culprit with a name: Weyer was not a practitioner but a skeptic who stated he left parts out to make the system unworkable. So the literary branch drops the Three Chiefs and much of the apparatus —not by accident of transmission, but by a hostile editor. The southern stream, by contrast, kept them.

What the manuscripts show

We can say this because we transcribed the witnesses ourselves, not because a handbook repeats it. Reading the Livre des Esperitz and the Liber Officiorum Spirituum side by side, a «braided river» appears (the image is J.-P. Boudet's): they share some 35 spirits —names almost always mangled: Beal/Baall, Agarat/Acharos, Barbas/Barbates, Forcas/Forcase, Oze/Ose…— next to a handful that show up in only one. Not a clean A→B pipe, but two branches of one older trunk. In our editions each correspondence is marked, and on every entry we anchor the demon to its oldest documented form.

Honest cautions

See also the Methodology, the Bibliography and the Library of texts.

See all 72 spirits

grimorium.lat · Documentary library of ritual magic, demonology and historical grimoires